Understanding Brazil ETFs: Investment Opportunities and Risks

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) from Brazil offer investors a way to access the Latin American giant’s economy. These funds trade on stock exchanges like stocks and hold assets from Brazilian entities, providing non-Brazilian investors with an opportunity to speculate in Brazil’s financial markets.


Key Takeaways:


– Brazil ETFs allow for geographical diversification of investment portfolios.


– Investors should consider expense ratios, liquidity, tracking errors, and the performance of the Brazilian stock market when evaluating Brazil ETFs.


– There are unique risks associated with investing in Brazil ETFs, such as currency risk, market volatility, and political and economic factors that can impact performance.


– Understanding the tax implications and regulations related to Brazilian ETFs is crucial.


Understanding the Brazilian Market:


Brazil boasts the 11th-largest economy globally, with a GDP of $1.92 trillion as of 2022, surpassing countries like Australia, South Korea, and Mexico. This economic growth is attributed to Brazil’s vast natural resources, diverse industrial base, and large workforce. However, the per-capita GDP of just under $9,000 in 2022, ranking 101st globally, highlights the challenges of uneven economic development.


Brazil’s economy, being a major commodities exporter, is sensitive to global commodity cycles and the strength of the Brazilian real (BRL) against the U.S. dollar. The country’s high benchmark interest rate, the SELIC rate, and fiscal reforms, trade pacts, and privatization efforts also influence equities trading and investor sentiment. Credit downgrades, such as Brazil’s loss of investment grade status in 2015, can affect foreign investment.


The B3 Exchange:


The B3 Exchange, the primary stock exchange in Brazil and the largest in Latin America, has a market capitalization of $913,387.25 million as of January 2024. It was formed in 2008 from the merger of BM&F Bovespa and Cetip and is headquartered in São Paulo. Over 352 companies’ stocks and more than 2,619 companies from all major industries are listed on the B3, trading electronically on its platforms. The B3 offers trading in options, futures, forwards, and Brazilian depositary receipts, enabling non-Brazilian companies to list shares.


The Ibovespa, Brazil’s benchmark equity index, tracks around 80 of the largest and most liquid Brazilian stocks by market cap. Other significant B3 indexes include the Brazil 100 Index, the Brazil 50 Index, the Brazil Broad-Based Index, and various sector-specific indexes.


The São Paulo Stock Exchange, known as B3, SA, is a prominent stock and OTC market based in Brazil. Founded in 1890 as Bolsa de Valores de São Paulo (BOVESPA), it has a rich history and plays a significant role in the global financial landscape.



When it comes to selecting the right Brazil ETFs, there are several key criteria to consider. As of 2024, six Brazil ETFs trade on American exchanges, excluding leveraged and inverse ETFs. These criteria include expense ratios, bid-ask spreads, trading volume, dividend yields, and the index or asset class tracked. Each of these factors is crucial in determining the suitability of an ETF for your investment goals.



Expense ratios represent the annual rate that the fund charges on its total assets to cover management, administration, and other costs. For long-term, buy-and-hold investors, lower expense ratios are generally more favorable, but they should be considered in the context of the ETF’s overall performance and goals.



The bid-ask spread is the difference between the highest price a buyer is willing to pay for an ETF share (bid) and the lowest price a seller is willing to accept (ask). This transaction cost affects the price at which you can buy or sell the ETF. A narrower bid-ask spread is generally better, as it signals more liquidity and lower trading costs.



Trading volume refers to the number of shares of the ETF traded daily. Higher trading volume typically indicates higher liquidity, making entering and exiting positions easier without greatly affecting the market price.



Dividend yield is the ratio of a company’s annual dividend compared with its share price. Higher dividend yields can be attractive for income-seeking investors, but it’s important to balance this with the overall investment strategy and growth potential of the ETF.



Understanding the specific index or asset class that the ETF tracks is crucial. This will determine the kind of exposure you’re getting into. Different ETFs may track broad market indexes, specific sectors, or unique asset classes, each with its own risk-return profile.



When evaluating these criteria, consider your investment goals, risk tolerance, and overall market conditions. For example, if you prioritize low costs, then you might focus on ETFs with lower expense ratios. Conversely, if your goal is to achieve more liquidity, then look for ETFs with high trading volumes and narrow bid-ask spreads.



Here’s a comparison of Brazil ETFs:


ETF Name: iShares MSCI Brazil ETF


Ticker: EWZ


Mandate: Tracks the MSCI Brazil 25/50 Index, which provides a broad-based measure of the performance of large-cap and midcap companies from the B3 exchange.


Expense Ratio: 0.59%


Total Assets: $5,810 million


Dividend Yield: 6.00%


2023 Performance: 29.5%


Average Daily Volume: 21,000,000



ETF Name: iShares MSCI Brazil Small-Cap ETF


Ticker: EWZS


Mandate: Tracks a market-cap-weighted index of Brazilian small-cap firms.


Expense Ratio: 0.59%


Total Assets: $250 million


Dividend Yield: 2.94%


2023 Performance: 29.1%


Average Daily Volume: 704,000



ETF Name: Franklin FTSE Brazil ETF


Ticker: FLBR


Mandate: Tracks a market-cap-weighted index of Brazilian large-cap and midcap stocks. Excludes small-caps.


Expense Ratio: N/A


Total Assets: N/A


Dividend Yield: N/A


2023 Performance: N/A


Average Daily Volume: N/A
Brazil ETFs come in various forms. For example, Direxion Daily MSCI Brazil Bull 2× Shares (BRZU) provides twice-daily leveraged exposure to a market-cap-weighted index of large-cap and midcap Brazilian companies. VanEck Brazil Small-Cap ETF (BRFT) tracks a market-cap-weighted index of Brazilian small-cap firms. ProShares UltraShort MSCI Brazil Capped (BZQ) offers twice-leveraged inverse exposure to a market-cap-weighted index of midcap and large-cap companies operating in Brazil. First Trust Brazil AlphaDEX Fund (FBZ) is an actively traded ETF that tries to select firms best positioned to outperform the market with a significant small-cap and midcap tilt. ProShares Ultra MSCI Brazil Capped (UBR) provides twice-daily leveraged exposure to a market-cap-weighted index comprising large-cap and midcap companies operating in Brazil, capturing about 85% of the Brazilian equity market. Global X Brazil Active ETF (BRAZ) seeks long-term capital growth by investing in a concentrated portfolio of Brazilian equities and uses bottom-up, fundamental analysis to select and manage its holdings.


When considering an investment in Brazil ETFs, several critical factors need to be assessed. The choice of market cap focus, whether large cap vs. small cap vs. broad, greatly affects the investment. Large-cap ETFs mainly consist of mega- and large-cap stocks and provide broad exposure to the Brazilian economy. Small-cap ETFs focus on smaller companies and offer a more direct play on local market dynamics. Broad-based ETFs cover all company sizes.


Many Brazilian companies have significant government ownership, which can influence company decisions and may not always align with shareholder interests. Large-cap ETFs tend to have higher allocations to state-owned companies, while small-cap ETFs usually give less weight to such stocks.


Sector biases are also important. International ETFs often prefer specific sectors. For Brazil ETFs, significant allocations are typically made to materials, financials, and energy sectors, while they might underallocate funds in industries like healthcare and consumer discretionary, which could be a concern given the expected growth in consumer spending due to the rising middle class in Brazil.


Currency exposure is another factor. Brazil ETFs likely have exposure to the Brazilian real, meaning that the ETF’s performance can be affected by currency fluctuations. If the Brazilian real strengthens against the U.S. dollar, it could positively affect the returns of Brazil ETFs.


Source: VettaFi (all data as of January 2024).
Brazil ETFs are a popular choice for U.S.-based investors looking to diversify their portfolios. Here’s what you need to know about how they work and the unique considerations involved.



Special Tax Considerations for U.S. Investors


Brazil has distinct tax policies that can impact the returns of U.S.-based investors. While a 2% tax on foreign equity investors was abolished, there’s a possibility of future taxes that could affect Brazil ETFs. Since 2023, the Brazilian government has been seeking ways to increase tax revenues to support its social agenda, primarily impacting Brazilian residents with foreign investments, with minimal effects on non-Brazilian holders of Brazil ETFs.



Government Instability and Market Impact


Political scandals, corruption investigations, and impeachment proceedings have contributed to volatile policy shifts in Brazil, leading to market uncertainty. Brazil has experienced significant fluctuations in inflation over the past two decades, peaking at over 14% in 2003, then ranging between 3% and 9% for the next 15 years, and reaching over 9% in 2022.



Liquidity Risk and Trading Costs


The liquidity of Brazil’s equities is generally lower than that of developed markets, which can increase trading costs for large orders. This liquidity can vary among Brazil ETFs, depending on their underlying holdings.



Market Volatility


Brazil’s stock market is known for its extreme fluctuations, experiencing booms and busts in line with its economy, compared to more stable developed markets.



Strategies to Mitigate Risk When Investing in Brazil


Investing in Brazil comes with risks, but these can be managed to enhance a diversified portfolio by following prudent investment principles:


– Diversify across sectors, market caps, stocks, and geographic regions to avoid overexposure to any part of the Brazilian market.


– Limit your allocation to Brazil, with many advisors suggesting a total emerging markets exposure of 5% to 10% of a portfolio.


– Choose large, more established Brazil ETFs with ample liquidity and transparent holdings.


– Balance Brazilian equities with stable assets like bonds, cash, and developed market stocks.


– Hedge currency exposure through ETFs that neutralize the effects of a weakening Brazilian real.



How to Buy Shares in a Brazil ETF


Most brokerage platforms offer Brazil ETFs. To invest, research and identify the ETFs that interest you, then use your broker’s order entry tool to trade. Many brokerages now offer commission-free trading in ETFs.



ETFs Listed on Brazil’s B3 Exchange


Yes, ETFs are listed on Brazil’s B3 stock exchange, providing investors with a variety of options covering different sectors and investment strategies. These ETFs offer a diversified and often more cost-effective approach to investing in the Brazilian market compared to direct stock investments. The specific ETFs available on B3 cater to various investment needs and preferences, allowing Brazil-based investors to choose according to their investment goals and risk tolerance.



Advantages of Brazil ETFs Over Individual Stocks or ADRs


Brazil ETFs offer several benefits over selecting individual Brazilian stocks or American depositary receipts (ADRs) for your portfolio.
Brazil ETFs provide instant diversification across numerous holdings, reducing company-specific risks. They allow participation in the broader Brazilian stock market instead of choosing a few winning stocks. U.S.-based brokers might not offer direct access to Brazilian stock markets, and not all interesting Brazilian companies have ADRs traded on American exchanges. Even if access exists, these ETFs simplify owning foreign shares. With diversification, liquidity, transparency, low costs, and currency hedging capabilities, they have many advantages over individual Brazilian stocks and ADRs.


What is Brazil’s greatest source of wealth? It’s rich natural resources and diversified economy. The country is a major global producer of commodities like soybeans, corn, coffee, sugar, and beef. It also has significant mineral reserves including iron ore, gold, and bauxite. Additionally, Brazil has invested in renewable energy, with a large part of its energy matrix coming from hydro, wind, and biomass sources. The industrial sector, especially steel production, and the service sector, which contributes a large part of its GDP, are key to Brazil’s wealth.


The bottom line is that Brazil ETFs are a good option for American investors seeking geographic diversification to the Brazilian markets with unique dynamics and opportunities. However, understanding the nuances of the Brazilian market, recognizing the risks, and aligning with your investment strategy is crucial.


The comments, opinions, and analyses expressed are for informational purposes only and not individual investment advice or recommendations. We believe the information is reliable but do not warrant its accuracy or completeness. The views and strategies may not be suitable for all investors. Due to rapid market and economic changes, all content is as of the posting date and may change without notice. The material is not a complete analysis of every fact regarding any country, region, market, industry, investment, or strategy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *